Manchester United Player Ratings: Who Dominates and Who Struggles in the 2025/26 Season

Manchester United fans rejoice as their team delivers a stunning 2-0 victory over rivals Manchester City on January 17, 2026, at Old Trafford. Bryan Mbeumo scores a clinical goal, and Patrick Dorgu seals the win with a sharp finish. This match highlights the Red Devils’ resurgence under head coach Michael Carrick, who starts his tenure with a bang. Fans search for the latest player ratings to understand who drives the success and who needs to step up. This article dives deep into recent match ratings, overall season performances, key statistics, player analyses, and future outlooks. You gain insights that satisfy your curiosity about Manchester United’s form, backed by reliable data from sources like FotMob, Manchester Evening News, Sports Illustrated, and The Athletic. Moreover, you discover how these ratings reflect broader trends in the Premier League. Let’s explore what makes this squad tick.

Manchester United’s Epic Derby Win: Player Ratings from the 2-0 Triumph Over Manchester City

Manchester United outplays Manchester City in every department during their Premier League clash on January 17, 2026. The Red Devils control possession, create numerous chances, and defend stoutly to secure a clean sheet. Bryan Mbeumo opens the scoring with a well-taken volley, while Patrick Dorgu adds the second after a clever assist from substitute Matheus Cunha. This performance earns high praise across the board, with several players achieving ratings of 8 or above. Experts from Manchester Evening News and Sports Illustrated provide detailed breakdowns, showing how individual brilliance combines to produce team success. You see Bruno Fernandes orchestrate the midfield, while the defense shuts down Erling Haaland effectively.

Goalkeeper: Senne Lammens Shines with Composure

Senne Lammens commands his area confidently throughout the match. He makes a crucial save from Max Alleyne’s header and handles crosses with authority. Despite conceding an unnecessary corner early on, Lammens recovers swiftly and maintains a clean sheet. Manchester Evening News awards him a 7, noting his good hands in the second half. Sports Illustrated rates him at 7.8, praising his distribution that launches quick counters. Lammens’ performance builds on his season form, where he earns a 6.94 average rating from FotMob across 16 appearances.

Additionally, his three Player of the Match awards this season underscore his reliability. Fans appreciate how Lammens steps up after Andre Onana’s departure, providing stability that allows the defense to push forward aggressively. His quick reflexes prevent City from gaining momentum, and his long balls find Amad Diallo and Patrick Dorgu effectively. This match cements Lammens as a key figure in United’s revival, showing why the club invests in young talent from Belgium.

Defenders: A Rock-Solid Backline Stifles City’s Attack

Harry Maguire dominates aerial duels and keeps Erling Haaland quiet. He nearly scores with an early header that hits the woodwork but excels defensively. Manchester Evening News rates him 8, calling his performance front-footed and excellent against Haaland. Sports Illustrated agrees with 7.6, emphasizing his command. In nine appearances this season, Maguire scores once and assists once, maintaining solidity despite limited starts.

Lisandro Martinez reads the game brilliantly and blocks Haaland’s shot superbly. He stays calm on the ball and positions himself perfectly. Manchester Evening News awards him 7, praising his sliding block and possession play. Sports Illustrated gives 7.4 for his composure. Across 10 games, Martinez intercepts six times, showcasing his World Cup-winning experience.

Luke Shaw copes well with Antoine Semenyo and Phil Foden, delivering an intelligent display despite an early booking. Manchester Evening News rates him 7, noting his energy up and down the wing. Sports Illustrated scores 7.1. Shaw leads the squad with 22 appearances, assisting once and winning 26 tackles, with a 6.85 FotMob rating. His return from injury boosts United’s left side, allowing overlaps that create space for attackers.

The defense collectively limits City to one shot on target, proving their cohesion. Matthijs de Ligt, though not starting this match, contributes in 13 games with a 6.97 rating, scoring once. Leny Yoro adds depth with 21 appearances and a 6.55 rating, focusing on progressive passes.

Midfielders: Casemiro and Mainoo Control the Engine Room

Casemiro delivers a magnificent holding performance, recovering the ball from Haaland and tackling relentlessly. He nearly scores but shines in breaking up play. Manchester Evening News awards him 9, calling it a masterclass. Sports Illustrated rates 7.4. In 20 appearances, Casemiro scores four goals and assists once, with a 7.17 FotMob rating and one Player of the Match award. His 26 tackles won highlight his defensive anchor role.

Kobbie Mainoo shimmies past opponents and deserves more starts. He shows carelessness once but impresses overall. Manchester Evening News gives 7, praising his talents. Sports Illustrated scores 7.5. With 13 appearances, Mainoo focuses on building play from deep.

Bruno Fernandes thrives as a No. 10, assisting Mbeumo’s goal with a perfect pass and creating chances. An offside call denies him a goal. Manchester Evening News rates 8, saying it’s Bruno at his best. Sports Illustrated awards 8.7, noting his vision. Fernandes tops the season charts with 19 appearances, five goals, nine assists, and a 7.96 FotMob rating, plus seven Player of the Match awards. His 19 tackles won add defensive bite.

Manuel Ugarte substitutes late, earning 6 from Manchester Evening News and N/A from Sports Illustrated. In 16 games, he wins 23 tackles with a 6.72 rating.

Forwards: Mbeumo and Dorgu Lead the Charge

Amad Diallo torments City’s left side, hitting the post and threatening constantly. Manchester Evening News awards 8, calling him a livewire. Sports Illustrated gives 7.5. In 16 appearances, Amad scores twice and assists twice, with a 7.50 FotMob rating.

Patrick Dorgu surprises with his selection but impacts massively, volleying well and scoring alertly. Manchester Evening News rates 8, praising his sharpness. Sports Illustrated awards 8.5. Dorgu appears in 21 games, scoring twice and assisting three times, with a 7.20 rating.

Bryan Mbeumo works tirelessly, scores clinically, and pulls defenders out of position. Manchester Evening News gives 8, noting his movement. Sports Illustrated rates 7.5. Leading scorer with seven goals in 17 games, Mbeumo earns a 7.25 rating and one Player of the Match.

Matheus Cunha substitutes and assists Dorgu’s goal while tackling back. Manchester Evening News awards 7, Sports Illustrated 7.4. In 19 appearances, Cunha scores four and assists twice, with a 7.17 rating.

Mason Mount enters late, nearly scores but offside rules it out. He gets 7 from Manchester Evening News, N/A from Sports Illustrated. Mount appears in 17 games, scoring three times with a 6.82 rating.

Ayden Heaven debuts briefly, earning 6. In 11 appearances, he assists once with defensive contributions.

This match propels United to fifth in the league, showcasing their potential.

Overall Season Ratings: How Manchester United Players Stack Up in 2025/26

Manchester United sits fifth in the Premier League after 22 matches, scoring consistently while tightening defensively. FotMob provides average ratings, while The Athletic details stats like goals and assists. Bruno Fernandes leads with 7.96, followed by Amad at 7.50. The team scores 36 goals, with Mbeumo topping at seven. Fernandes dominates assists with nine. Goalkeepers secure three clean sheets, defenders win key duels, midfielders control tempo, and forwards convert chances. However, inconsistencies in some areas highlight needs for improvement.

Goalkeepers: Stability Between the Posts

Senne Lammens starts 16 games, making 34 saves and keeping three clean sheets. His 6.94 rating reflects growth. Altay Bayindir appears in six, conceding 11 but showing promise. Tom Heaton and Andre Onana remain unused, providing depth.

Defenders: Building from the Back

Luke Shaw anchors with 22 starts, assisting once and winning 26 tackles. Patrick Dorgu excites with two goals in 21 games. Leny Yoro intercepts 16 times in 21 appearances. Diogo Dalot balances attack and defense in 20 games. Matthijs de Ligt scores once in 13 starts. Ayden Heaven emerges in 11 games. Lisandro Martinez and Harry Maguire add experience, with Maguire scoring in nine outings. Noussair Mazraoui tackles seven times in nine. Others like Tyrell Malacia offer rotation.

Midfielders: Creativity and Grit

Casemiro starts 19 of 20, scoring four. Bruno Fernandes starts all 19, with five goals and nine assists. Mason Mount scores three in 17. Manuel Ugarte wins 23 tackles in 16. Kobbie Mainoo builds in 13. Jack Fletcher appears thrice.

Forwards: Firepower Up Front

Matheus Cunha starts 16 of 19, scoring four. Bryan Mbeumo nets seven in 17. Benjamin Sesko scores four in 17. Amad Diallo adds two in 16. Joshua Zirkzee scores two in 14. Alejandro Garnacho scores once in five. Jadon Sancho appears thrice. Shea Lacey excites in two.

These ratings and stats show United’s balance, but consistency wins titles

Youngsters like Ayden Heaven (CB sub) and Shea Lacey add promise, while veterans like Maguire ensure stability. This blend fuels United’s top-four push, though consistency remains key.​

Top Performers: Players Who Elevate Manchester United This Season

Bruno Fernandes captains with flair, earning 7.96 and seven Player of the Match awards. He creates chances relentlessly, assists nine times, and scores five. Fans chant his name as he drives United forward. Amad Diallo bursts onto scenes with 7.50, scoring twice and assisting twice. His dribbling troubles defenders. Bryan Mbeumo leads scoring with seven, rating 7.25. He presses high and finishes sharply. Patrick Dorgu adapts quickly, scoring twice with 7.20. Casemiro anchors at 7.17, winning duels. Matheus Cunha adds versatility at 7.17. These stars propel United’s top-five push.

Bruno Fernandes: The Maestro in Midfield

Bruno Fernandes transforms games with vision. He completes 30 shots, 13 on target, and wins 19 tackles. His leadership inspires teammates. Compared to past seasons, Fernandes maintains high standards, evolving into a complete midfielder. Analysts predict he breaks double digits in goals and assists soon.

Bryan Mbeumo: The Goal Machine

Mbeumo takes 39 shots, 26 on target, scoring seven. He wins five tackles and earns 20 fouls. His Cameroon international status boosts confidence. Mbeumo outperforms expectations, drawing comparisons to United legends like Ruud van Nistelrooy in finishing.

Amad Diallo: The Rising Star

Amad dribbles past opponents, scoring two and assisting two. He wins 14 tackles and earns 26 fouls. His Ivory Coast roots add flair. Diallo’s growth from loans positions him as a future mainstay.

Areas for Improvement: Where Manchester United Must Strengthen

Some players lag behind. Benjamin Sesko rates 6.68, scoring four but missing chances. Leny Yoro at 6.55 needs polish despite interceptions. Manuel Ugarte at 6.72 wins tackles but lacks creativity. The team concedes too many in away games. Carrick addresses these by rotating and training intensively. Moreover, injuries to key players like Garnacho limit options. United targets consistency to challenge for top four.

Defensive Vulnerabilities

The backline secures only three clean sheets. Yoro commits 11 fouls, risking cards. De Ligt at 6.97 must integrate faster.

Attacking Efficiency

Sesko takes 33 shots but converts only four. Zirkzee at two goals needs more starts.

Historical Context: How 2025/26 Ratings Compare to Past Seasons

Stockport county F.C Manchester United’s current ratings echo the 2022/23 resurgence under Erik ten Hag, where Fernandes rated similarly high. However, this season’s defense improves from last year’s leaks, with Maguire echoing his Euro 2024 form. Mbeumo’s goals rival Rashford’s peak. The squad blends youth like Mainoo with veterans like Casemiro, reminiscent of Sir Alex Ferguson’s mixes. Ratings rise from mid-table struggles, signaling a return to glory. Fans recall 1999’s treble winners, where midfield dominance won titles. Carrick draws from that era, pushing players to new heights.

Evolution of Key Players

Fernandes evolves from penalty specialist to all-rounder. Casemiro recaptures Real Madrid form. Youngsters like Dorgu mirror Giggs’ breakthroughs.

Future Outlook: What These Ratings Mean for Manchester United’s Campaign

Caroline Flack Funeral High ratings position United for Champions League spots. Fernandes and Mbeumo drive title challenges if consistency holds. Carrick builds on the City win, targeting FA Cup and Europa League success. Transfers in January could boost depth. Fans expect top-four finish, with ratings predicting strong second half. Moreover, youth integration like Heaven ensures longevity.

Predictions Based on Data

United scores more in home games. Ratings suggest wins against mid-table sides. Fernandes hits 15 assists.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Who holds the highest Manchester United player rating in 2026?

Kai Widdrington Bruno Fernandes leads with an 8.7 in the Manchester City derby, excelling through vision and passing that unlocked defenses repeatedly. His season-long consistency and EA FC 26 80+ rating cement his status as the squad’s linchpin, driving attacks with creativity fans adore.​

How did Patrick Dorgu perform in recent matches?

Patrick Dorgu earned an 8.5 rating against City, providing width and forcing fouls while aiding the second goal. His pace and directness trouble full-backs, marking him as a breakout star in Carrick’s system with strong EA pace stats.

What are Kobbie Mainoo’s key contributions this season?

Kobbie Mainoo scored a 7/10 versus Brighton, creating three early chances on his first start since August. The young midfielder showcases composure and vision, filling a void in United’s engine room effectively.​

Why did Diogo Dalot receive low ratings lately?

Freddie Flintoff Shocking Diogo Dalot managed only 4/10 against Brighton due to defensive errors that left gaps. Despite his 79 EA overall and attacking strengths, he must tighten up to reclaim top form.

How does Manuel Ugarte rate across games?

Manuel Ugarte improved to 6/10 versus Burnley with solid defending and a key run, though he hit 5/10 at Brighton for passing issues. His 80 CDM EA rating highlights potential.

What role does Bruno Fernandes play in United’s tactics?

Bruno Fernandes thrives as a No. 10 under Carrick, earning 8.7 ratings with outstanding vision. He also works tirelessly in defense, as seen at 6/10 versus Brighton.

Who are Manchester United’s top-rated center-backs?

Harry Maguire (7.6) and Lisandro Martínez (7.4) dominated Haaland in the derby. Both boast 80 EA ratings, excelling in duels and blocks.

How has Benjamin Sesko impacted United?

Benjamin Sesko went from zero to hero against Burnley, scoring crucially. His striker prowess aligns with high EA potential ratings.

What do EA Sports FC 26 ratings reveal about the squad?

EA rates Fernandes, Cunha, and Mbeumo highest at 80+, with depth in midfield (Ugarte 80) and defense. These reflect real-world impacts accurately.​

Can Manchester United players compete for top-four spots?

Fans argue United lack league-top players broadly, but stars like Fernandes rank elite. Recent ratings under Carrick suggest a top-four push remains viable

To Get More News Insights Click On:

Heartbreaking Losses: Gogglebox Stars Who Have Passed Away – Latest Tributes and Memories

How Old Is Karen Carney The Full Story of a Football Legend Turned Media Star

Freddie Flintoff’s Accident, His Brave Recovery and 2026 Updates

Zoe Ball and Rylan Clark Emerge as Top Picks to Replace Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman on Strictly Come Dancing

To Get More Info: Yorkshire Herald